Recently I virtualized most of the servers I had at home into an ESXi 5.1 platform. This post would follow my journey to achieve better network performance between the VMs.
I am quite happy with the setup as it allowed me to eliminate 5-6 physical boxes in favor of one (very strong) machine. I was also able to achieve some performance improvements but not to the degree I hoped to see.
I have a variety of machines running in a virtualized form:
1. Windows 8 as my primary desktop, passing dedicated GPU and USB card.from the host to the VM using VMDirectPath
2. Multiple Linux servers
3. Solaris 11.1 as NAS, running the great napp-it software (http://www.napp-it.org/)
All the machines have the latest VMware Tools installed and running paravirtualized drivers where possible.
VM to VM network performance has been great between the Windows/Linux boxes once I enabled Jumbo Frames.
Throughout this post I'll use iperf to measure network performance. It's a great and easy to use tool and you can find precompiled version for almost any operating system. http://iperf.fr/
Let's start with an example of network throughput performance from the Windows 8 Machine to Linux:
11.3 Gbps, not bad. CPU utilization was around 25% on the windows box throughout the test.
Network performance between the Solaris VM and any other machine on the host was relatively bad.
I started by using the E1000G virtual adapter, as recommended by VMware for Solaris 11 (http://kb.vmware.com/kb/2032669). We'll use one of my Linux VMs (at 192.168.1.202) as a server for these tests. using iperf to test:
1.36 Gbps. Not bad between physical servers, but unacceptable between VMs on the same host. also notice the very high CPU utilization during the test - around 80% system time.
My immediate instinct was to enable jumbo frames. Although the adapter driver is supposed to support jumbo frames, I was unable to enable it no matter how hard I fought it.
root@solaris-lab:/kernel/drv# dladm set-linkprop -p mtu=9000 net0
dladm: warning: cannot set link property 'mtu' on 'net0': link busy
I gave up on getting better performance from the E1000G adapter and switched to VMXNET3. I immediately saw improvement:
2.31 Gbps. but more importantly, the cpu utilization was much lower.
Now let's try to enable jumbo frames for the vmxnet3 adapter - followed the steps in http://kb.vmware.com/kb/2012445 and http://kb.vmware.com/kb/2032669 without success. The commands work, but jumbo frames were not really enabled. we can test with 9000 byte ping -
root@solaris-lab:~# ping -s 192.168.1.202 9000 4
PING 192.168.1.202: 9000 data bytes
----192.168.1.202 PING Statistics----
4 packets transmitted, 0 packets received, 100% packet loss
As my next step I was planning on running some dtrace commands, and accidentally noticed that the drivers I have installed are the Solaris 10 version and not the Solaris 11 version.
root@solaris-lab:~/vmware-tools-distrib# find /kernel/drv/ -ls |grep vmxnet3
78669 2 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1071 Mar 27 01:42 /kernel/drv/vmxnet3s.conf
78671 34 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 34104 Mar 27 01:42 /kernel/drv/amd64/vmxnet3s
78670 25 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 24440 Mar 27 01:42 /kernel/drv/vmxnet3s
root@solaris-lab:~/vmware-tools-distrib# find . -ls |grep vmxnet3
231 25 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 24528 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/2009.06/vmxnet3s
234 2 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1071 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/2009.06/vmxnet3s.conf
250 2 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1071 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/10/vmxnet3s.conf
244 25 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 24440 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/10/vmxnet3s
262 34 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 34104 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/10_64/vmxnet3s
237 35 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 35240 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/11_64/vmxnet3s
227 34 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 34256 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/2009.06_64/vmxnet3s
253 25 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 24672 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/11/vmxnet3s
259 2 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1071 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/11/vmxnet3s.conf
This is very strange as installation of the Tools is a straightforward procedure with no room for user error.
So I decided to open the Tools installation script (perl) and found an interesting bug -
...
sub configure_module_solaris {
my $module = shift;
my %patch;
my $dir = db_get_answer('LIBDIR') . '/modules/binary/';
my ($major, $minor) = solaris_os_version();
my $os_name = solaris_os_name();
my $osDir;
my $osFlavorDir;
my $currentMinor = 10; # The most recent version we build the drivers for
if (solaris_10_or_greater() ne "yes") {
print "VMware Tools for Solaris is only available for Solaris 10 and later.\n";
return 'no';
}
if ($minor < $currentMinor) {
$osDir = $minor;
} else {
$osDir = $currentMinor;
}
For Solaris 11.1, $minor is 11, which forces $osDir to be Solaris 10. Bug ?Either way it's very easy to fix - just change "<" to ">":
if ($minor > $currentMinor) {
Re-install Tools using the modified script and reboot. Let's check the installed driver now:
root@solaris-lab:~/vmware-tools-distrib# find /kernel/drv/ -ls |grep vmxnet3
79085 2 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1071 Mar 27 02:00 /kernel/drv/vmxnet3s.conf
79087 35 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 35240 Mar 27 02:00 /kernel/drv/amd64/vmxnet3s
79086 25 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 24672 Mar 27 02:00 /kernel/drv/vmxnet3s
root@solaris-lab:~/vmware-tools-distrib# find . -ls |grep vmxnet3
231 25 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 24528 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/2009.06/vmxnet3s
234 2 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1071 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/2009.06/vmxnet3s.conf
250 2 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1071 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/10/vmxnet3s.conf
244 25 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 24440 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/10/vmxnet3s
262 34 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 34104 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/10_64/vmxnet3s
237 35 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 35240 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/11_64/vmxnet3s
227 34 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 34256 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/2009.06_64/vmxnet3s
253 25 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 24672 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/11/vmxnet3s
259 2 -rw-r--r-- 1 root root 1071 Nov 17 07:55 ./lib/modules/binary/11/vmxnet3s.conf
Now we have the correct version installed.
Let's enable jumbo-frames as before and check if it made any difference:
root@solaris-lab:~# ping -s 192.168.1.202 9000 4
PING 192.168.1.202: 9000 data bytes
9008 bytes from 192.168.1.202: icmp_seq=0. time=0.338 ms
9008 bytes from 192.168.1.202: icmp_seq=1. time=0.230 ms
9008 bytes from 192.168.1.202: icmp_seq=2. time=0.289 ms
9008 bytes from 192.168.1.202: icmp_seq=3. time=0.294 ms
----192.168.1.202 PING Statistics----
4 packets transmitted, 4 packets received, 0% packet loss
round-trip (ms) min/avg/max/stddev = 0.230/0.288/0.338/0.044
Success! jumbo-frames are working.
Let's test throughput with iperf:
Less than 1Mb/s, not what we expected at all!
Need to take a deeper look at the packets being sent. Let's use tcpdump to create a trace file:
root@solaris-lab:~# tcpdump -w pkts.pcap -s 100 -inet1 & PID=$! ; sleep 1s ; ./iperf -t1 -c192.168.1.202; kill $PID
[1] 1726
tcpdump: listening on net1, link-type EN10MB (Ethernet), capture size 100 bytes
------------------------------------------------------------
Client connecting to 192.168.1.202, TCP port 5001
TCP window size: 48.0 KByte (default)
------------------------------------------------------------
[ 3] local 192.168.1.206 port 35084 connected with 192.168.1.202 port 5001
[ ID] Interval Transfer Bandwidth
[ 3] 0.0- 1.3 sec 168 KBytes 1.02 Mbits/sec
70 packets captured
70 packets received by filter
0 packets dropped by kernel
and open it in Wireshark for easier analysis:
The problem is clear with packet 7 - the driver is trying to send a 16KB packet, above our 9K MTU jumbo frame. This packet is not received outside of the VM and after a timeout it is being fragmented and retransmitted. This happens again for every packet generating a massive delay and causes throughput to be very low.
Reviewing the vmxnet3 driver source (open source at http://sourceforge.net/projects/open-vm-tools/) it seems the only way a packet larger than the MTU to be sent is if the LSO feature is enabled.
To learn more about LSO (Large Segment Offload) read http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_segment_offload.
Essentially, the kernel is sending large packets (16K in the capture) and the NIC (or virtual NIC) is supposed to fragment the packet and transmit valid-size packets. On a real hardware NIC, at high speeds, this saves considerable amounts of CPU. in a virtualized environment I don't see the benefit. And it seems to be badly broken.
Let's disable LSO:
ndd -set /dev/ip ip_lso_outbound 0
And try to run iperf again:
12.1 Gbps, SUCCESS!
Now that that we are able to transmit from Solaris out in decent rates, let's check the performance of connections into the Solaris VM:
3.74 Gbps, not bad, but we can do better - let's at least get to 10Gbps.
Next step is to tune the TCP parameters to accommodate the higher speed needed - the buffers are simply too small for the amount of data in flight -
root@solaris-lab:~# ipadm set-prop -p max_buf=4194304 tcp
root@solaris-lab:~# ipadm set-prop -p recv_buf=1048576 tcp
root@solaris-lab:~# ipadm set-prop -p send_buf=1048576 tcp
And run iperf again:
18.3 Gbps, Not bad!
Hey, cool write up! :-)
ReplyDeleteI think there is an error in the code that detects the solaris version.
This line:
if ($minor < $currentMinor) {
should be:
if ($minor > $currentMinor) {
/Jannich
Thank you for the comment, I've fixed the typo.
DeleteGreat Article Cyber Security Projects projects for cse Networking Security Projects JavaScript Training in Chennai JavaScript Training in Chennai The Angular Training covers a wide range of topics including Components, Angular Directives, Angular Services, Pipes, security fundamentals, Routing, and Angular programmability. The new Angular TRaining will lay the foundation you need to specialise in Single Page Application developer. Angular Training
DeleteI always wanted to put my solaris box on the ESXI, but the abysmal network performance killed it.
ReplyDeleteThis is super helpful!
FYI, when testing pinging with jumbo frames, you need to allow 28 bytes for the IP and ICMP headers, try 8972 instead of 9000 on your ping command ;-)
ReplyDeleteGreat writeup, would love to see a post with more specifics on your hardware setup.
ReplyDeletefantastic!
ReplyDeleteTCP performance is related to delay (RTT) and TCP window size (if we don't have any loss). You should use -w in iperf to define window size and remake the same test on windows and linux PC
ReplyDeleteGreat write up and shows amazing results.. Thanks for spending your time to provide such information greatly appreciated..
ReplyDeleteYou could enable jumbo frame on e1000g vnic by changing MaxFrameSize in /kernel/drv/e1000g.conf
ReplyDeleteDefault:
MaxFrameSize=0,0,0,0 ...
Change to:
MaxFrameSize=3,3,3,3 ...
Reboot.
-----
Anyway, thanks for ipadm set-prop tips.
Regards.
The Solaris vmxnet3 driver has so many problems:
ReplyDelete- the LSO problem (there's a source patch that claims to fix the problem, but I haven't tried it: http://www.mail-archive.com/open-vm-tools-devel@lists.sourceforge.net/msg00812.html)
- the garbage debug output printed to console
- requiring the ndd 'accept-jumbo' flag to be set before MTU can be changed (why?!?!)
I'm seriously thinking about taking the source from open-vm-tools, throwing it on github, and fixing these problems
In the latest update 5.1 u1, the grabage output in the driver is fixed - after updating to the latest vmware tools, ndd accept-jumbo I was not able to test, same with lso, but will check and report back !
ReplyDeleteCan you pls help understand the latter part of the sentence "On a real hardware NIC, at high speeds, this saves considerable amounts of CPU. in a virtualized environment I don't see the benefit"
ReplyDeletei.e. why do you say there is no benefit?
thanks
Sure - on a real hardware NIC the segmentation is done in the NIC itself, meaning the host needs to build far less packets, calculate CRC, etc. the work of building the packet headers takes CPU on the host, and when offloaded to the hardware, can save can save considerable load. Now, in a virtualized environment, there is no physical hardware to build headers, but it is simulated by the ESXi host, still taking CPU. you are shifting load from the VM to the Host, but in total don't save any computation done on the main CPU.
ReplyDeleteHow were you able to hit speeds OVER 10Gbits/sec when the drivers itself is a 10Gb driver??
ReplyDeletePlease let me know, I've been testing with the vmxnet3 drivers in windows and linux.
Nothing is limiting the driver to 10Gb. It can go much faster.
DeleteNice post. But I don't understand why in my esxi 5.1 u1 lab, the iperf speed between my Windows Sever 2003 and a Linux is about 300Mbit/s, very pool. I didn't enable Jumbo frame, but those two have vmxnet3 driver installed.
ReplyDeleteCan somebody shed some lights for troubleshooting this?
I'd be happy to help.
Deletefirst step is to isolate the direction - are you getting 300Mb/s in both directions (linux->win and win->linux) ?
did you try to take a tcpdump and look at the results? I'd be happy to examine it for you.
Hi Cyber Explorer,
ReplyDeleteCan you share some tips for tuning Linux and Windows network performance if there is any?
My machine is not strong ( AMD 1.6Ghz x 2 ), but currently I get only 500Mbit/s transfer at max, no matter what OS it is, Linux, Windows, FreeBSD or Solaris. Is it normal?
my hunch is that you can do better. I don't have experience with these specific CPUs, but I have a standalone server (not virtualized) based on Intel Atom D510 and I am able to exhaust it's 1 GbE port after network tuning. I believe the D510 is weaker than your AMD cpus.
DeleteToday I tried to locate the problem. I have Windows Server 2003 R2 vm as a domain controller. And first I tried the iperf with the loop address to exclude other impacts. And the result is:
DeleteC:\iperf-2.0.5-2-win32>iperf.exe -c127.0.0.1
------------------------------------------------------------
Client connecting to 127.0.0.1, TCP port 5001
TCP window size: 64.0 KByte (default)
------------------------------------------------------------
[ 3] local 127.0.0.1 port 3004 connected with 127.0.0.1 port 5001
[ ID] Interval Transfer Bandwidth
[ 3] 0.0-10.0 sec 761 MBytes 637 Mbits/sec
C:\iperf-2.0.5-2-win32>iperf.exe -w 125K -c127.0.0.1
------------------------------------------------------------
Client connecting to 127.0.0.1, TCP port 5001
TCP window size: 125 KByte
------------------------------------------------------------
[ 3] local 127.0.0.1 port 3005 connected with 127.0.0.1 port 5001
[ ID] Interval Transfer Bandwidth
[ 3] 0.0-10.0 sec 814 MBytes 682 Mbits/sec
It would eat up 80% of CPU usage, so maybe it's a CPU problem, isn't it?
do you have jumbo frames enabled?
DeleteNope. Later I found that if I change window size to 1M, I can get 900Mbit/s throughput for loop address on Windows 2003. But I think it's Windows problem, because when testing iperf on my OpenIndiana vm through loop address, I can get 7Gbit/s, which is satisfying.
DeleteNow what can I do next? Since I still cannot get a satisfying speed between VMs under the same port group.
so that's the problem - enable jumbo frames on the windows box and you should get a much better throughput with lower cpu.
DeleteSince the physical switch which connects to the esxi server doesn't support jumbo frames, can I enable it on esxi? Will it influence the physical clients?
DeleteGood question, I'm not sure. best would be to simply try...
DeleteUSB passthrough is broken in 5.1. How were you able to pass GPU AND USB through on 5.1?? After doing your tuning, did you notice any other bugs with the vmxnet3 adapter?
ReplyDeleteI was able to stabilize USB pass-through on one specific version, any upgrade I attempted broke it and I had to roll back. It's ESXi 5.1.0 1021289.
DeleteSame goes for the USB PCI-E adapter: tried a few and only one worked - http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B005ARQV6U?ie=UTF8&camp=213733&creative=393185&creativeASIN=B005ARQV6U&linkCode=shr&tag=cybeblog-20&psc=1
As for other bugs - other than the known bug that's just making noise in the log, it's been extremely stable.
Deleteby the way, can you please show us your whitebox's spec, so we can use it as a reference?
ReplyDeleteThanks
I've been trying to break past an 800MB/sec nfs bottleneck between two linux guests on the same system using a standard vswitch with no physical nics assigned. i even tried bonding two different vswitches without any improvement. i also tried tweaking the various tcp window sizes. MTU is set to 9k, and tcpdump output appears to validate that:
ReplyDelete16:44:13.639338 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126259665:126268613, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
16:44:13.639347 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [P.], seq 126268613:126271513, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 2900
16:44:13.639355 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126271513:126280461, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
16:44:13.639359 IP nfsa.commplex-link > cgx.51236: Flags [.], ack 126241769, win 21993, options [nop,nop,TS val 78849579 ecr 74413494], length 0
16:44:13.639376 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126280461:126289409, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
16:44:13.639386 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126289409:126298357, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
16:44:13.639387 IP nfsa.commplex-link > cgx.51236: Flags [.], ack 126259665, win 21993, options [nop,nop,TS val 78849579 ecr 74413494], length 0
16:44:13.639393 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126298357:126307305, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
16:44:13.639400 IP nfsa.commplex-link > cgx.51236: Flags [.], ack 126280461, win 21927, options [nop,nop,TS val 78849579 ecr 74413494], length 0
16:44:13.639405 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126307305:126316253, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
16:44:13.639416 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [P.], seq 126316253:126320665, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 4412
16:44:13.639426 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126320665:126329613, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
16:44:13.639435 IP nfsa.commplex-link > cgx.51236: Flags [.], ack 126298357, win 21927, options [nop,nop,TS val 78849579 ecr 74413494], length 0
16:44:13.639435 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126329613:126338561, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
16:44:13.639444 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126338561:126347509, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
16:44:13.639453 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 126347509:126356457, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413494 ecr 78849579], length 8948
but the iperf numbers are not very good.
using the default frame sizes:
TCP window size: 29.0 KByte (default)
------------------------------------------------------------
[ 3] local 10.0.0.2 port 34335 connected with 10.0.0.1 port 5001
[ 3] 0.0-10.0 sec 5.20 GBytes 4.47 Gbits/sec
Server listening on TCP port 5001
TCP window size: 85.3 KByte (default)
------------------------------------------------------------
[ 4] local 10.0.0.1 port 5001 connected with 10.0.0.2 port 34335
[ 4] 0.0-10.0 sec 5.20 GBytes 4.46 Gbits/sec
using tweaked window sizes of 640KB etc, showed no difference.
the same issue is on both esxi 5.1.0 build 1065491 and 799733.
just can't seem to get pas the 4.5Gb/sec.
anyone have any thoughts?
wanted to add that the cpu usage is minimal. we are using the vmxnet3 drivers. i've tried various versions (the 1.1.18 through 1.1.29 and 1.1.32). also tried disabling LRO in the vmware settings (as some other web searches suggested), and the gso/tso/lro in the guest. none of the various combinations make any difference.
Deletecan you paste a longer tcpdump output, maybe through http://pastebin.com/ ?
DeletePlease include the tcp handshake, I want to see the window scale parameters.
My gut feeling is that you are exhausting your rcv buffers, although that should not kick in before 15-20Gbps on modern linux kernels and hardware.
this is from the first part of the tcpdump. i used the command you indicated earlier. i didn't want to post the whole thing. the section I posted earlier was from the middle. If you tell me what keywords you need (assuming this isn't it) I will look for them. here also is the sysctl settings I used which result in the same performance. I'm a little stumped because you said your linux2windows performance was fine. this is linux2linux (centos 6.2 - 2.6.32-220 to a 2.6.32-400).
Deletenet.core.rmem_max = 16777216
net.core.wmem_max = 16777216
##net.core.rmem_default = 33554432
##net.core.wmem_default = 33554432
net.ipv4.tcp_mem = 16777216 16777216 16777216
net.ipv4.tcp_rmem = 4096 873800 16777216
net.ipv4.tcp_wmem = 4096 655360 16777216
#net.ipv4.tcp_wmem = 4096 8738000 16777216
net.core.netdev_max_backlog = 30000
vm.min_free_kbytes = 2097152
and the beginning of the tcpdump...
16:44:13.416153 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [S], seq 1689649426, win 17920, options [mss 8960,sackOK,TS val 74413271 ecr 0,nop,wscale 7], length 0
16:44:13.416318 IP nfsa.commplex-link > cgx.51236: Flags [S.], seq 3605531965, ack 1689649427, win 17896, options [mss 8960,sackOK,TS val 78849356 ecr 74413271,nop,wscale 7], length 0
16:44:13.416358 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413271 ecr 78849356], length 0
16:44:13.416397 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [P.], seq 1:25, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413271 ecr 78849356], length 24
16:44:13.416425 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 25:8973, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413271 ecr 78849356], length 8948
16:44:13.416585 IP nfsa.commplex-link > cgx.51236: Flags [.], ack 25, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 78849356 ecr 74413271], length 0
16:44:13.416597 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 8973:17921, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413271 ecr 78849356], length 8948
16:44:13.416632 IP nfsa.commplex-link > cgx.51236: Flags [.], ack 8973, win 272, options [nop,nop,TS val 78849356 ecr 74413271], length 0
16:44:13.416647 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [P.], seq 17921:26869, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413271 ecr 78849356], length 8948
16:44:13.416667 IP cgx.51236 > nfsa.commplex-link: Flags [.], seq 26869:35817, ack 1, win 140, options [nop,nop,TS val 74413271 ecr 78849356], length 8948
16:44:13.416667 IP nfsa.commplex-link > cgx.51236: Flags [.], ack 17921, win 227, options [nop,nop,TS val 78849357 ecr 74413271], length 0
these are the original defaults on one of the nodes (before any sysctl changes). we have two different physical hosts. they both have the same guests. we've been experimenting with changing the sysctl settings on one to see what effect it has have and kept the other physical host's guests the same as the defaults.
Delete[root@cgx1 /]# sysctl -a | grep rcv
net.ipv4.tcp_moderate_rcvbuf = 1
[root@cgx1 /]# sysctl -a | grep recv
[root@cgx1 /]# sysctl -a | grep rmem
net.core.rmem_max = 131071
net.core.rmem_default = 124928
net.ipv4.tcp_rmem = 4096 87380 4194304
net.ipv4.udp_rmem_min = 4096
so far, both are performing exactly the same.
the tcpdump command you are using is correct - but i need a longer snippet to try and understand the flow of packates, at least a few thousands lines. best would be to paste it at a site like http://pastebin.com/, and then reply with the link to the paste here.
DeleteAlso, it's much easier to troubleshoot with iperf than NFS (or anything else). can you run the tcpdump with iperf traffic?
One more request - run tcpdump on both nodes concurrently when you test with iperf and attach the log.
I did run it with iperf. I used EXACTLY the command you gave above in your original post.
Deletei ran it again to get both client and server
server: http://pastebin.com/m5vXBv0U
client: http://pastebin.com/EHQAW0Lr
Sorry for taking the time to answer, I've been traveling for work.
ReplyDeleteThe traces are very interesting. Nothing in the packet flow/congestion seems to limit the performance at all.
The issue is the rate you are sending packets out - once every 7-10uS. My linux boxes send packets out every 1-2uS, until they reach a buffer/bandwidth bottleneck at around 22 Gbps.
anything on your system that can limit sending packets? for example, is it a multi core cpu with one core pegged at 100% ?
maybe (but unlikely) a packet shaper or firewall on the machine?
firewall is chkconfiged off (iptables and ip6tables)
Delete8 vcpu's are assigned. the physical host is dual cpu each cpu has 6 hyperthreaded cores. i don't see any single cpu limited.
as far as i know, no packet shaper is on. it is a stock centos 6.2 install on one, and an stock 6.2 with upgrades to 2.6.32-400 on the other (for ocfs2).
I'll try to install over the weekend the same configuration and see what performance i get. will let you know what i find.
DeleteI used a livecd for centos 6.2, straight out of the box installed iperf, enabled mtu 9000 and getting 15-20Gbps... nothing installed or touched on the box beyond that - vanilla drivers, not even vmware tools drivers.
Deletebefore enabling mtu 9000 I was exactly the exact problem as you were seeing.
can you please post the output of -
ethtool -i eth0
ifconfig eth0
this is the output for eth1. eth0 has a physical nic associated with it for management. eth1 is the purely virtual guest-2-guest vswitch.
Delete[root@cgx1 ~]# ethtool -i eth1
driver: vmxnet3
version: 1.1.18.0-k-NAPI
firmware-version: N/A
bus-info: 0000:1b:00.0
[root@cgx1 ~]# ifconfig eth1
eth1 Link encap:Ethernet HWaddr 00:0C:29:7E:CD:6E
inet addr:10.0.0.1 Bcast:10.0.0.255 Mask:255.255.255.0
inet6 addr: fe80::20c:29ff:fe7e:cd6e/64 Scope:Link
UP BROADCAST RUNNING MULTICAST MTU:9000 Metric:1
RX packets:13255527 errors:0 dropped:149 overruns:0 frame:0
TX packets:16059506 errors:0 dropped:0 overruns:0 carrier:0
collisions:0 txqueuelen:1000
RX bytes:5981766938 (5.5 GiB) TX bytes:159450144144 (148.4 GiB)
that is identical to what i see on mine, but i'm getting much better throughput.
Deleteone way to continue troubleshooting, would be to create another VM, run centos 6.2 live cd, install perf, run ifconfig eth0 mtu 9000 and test. if this shows good performance, you need to understand the delta between the livecd and your instance.
I have a question about the version bug in Solaris where vmtools installs for version 10 instead of 11. Is this still in the code cause i cant find the line to change. The problem is that i also have version 10 installed and when i do "uname -r" i get 5.11 meaning i should have version 11 installed. Do you mind telling us where (if still exists) in the code we need to change the "<" and ">"?
ReplyDeletewhat version of ESXi do you use? can you paste the installation script (or at least the relevant parts) over at http://pastebin.com and reply with the url?
DeleteAhh finally found it, thought it was in the "vmware-install.pl" but it's actually in a subfolder "./bin/vmware-config-tools.pl". Hopefully this will help someone =) and thx for very useful blogpost!
DeleteI have never, ever.....gotten vmxnet3 to perform correctly in esx aio. NFS share disconnects from ESX all the time, no matter what the MTU. e1000g just works. This is the same in ESXi 5.5
ReplyDeleteI'm trying to boost my speed from my Win7 VM to my Ubuntu12.04 VM and I can't seem to get past 2Gbps in either direction. From what I can tell I have Jumbo Frames enabled on both and I'm using the VMXNET3 driver on each. Link states 10gbps on each. When I just run the default client and servers I'm stuck at 2Gbps but if I explicitly set the window size with the -w flag on each I can get up to about 6Gbps. My questions are: if TCP is configured properly shouldn't the window size scale automatically without being set? When I transfer files over SMB/CIFS I can't seem to move past the 2Gbps limit either (I've got an SSD capable of going faster)
ReplyDeleteWell, I'm at about 4Gbps with iperf after realizing that the splashtop streamer I was running to remotely connect to the VM was slowing the iperf results. But the RWIN still doesn't seem to be auto scaling enough. It will go up to 10gbps if I set window size manually or connect multiple instances with -P but should I have to do that?
ReplyDeleteIn my experience it should not make a difference. are the results identical if you use the windows as servers vs. linux as server?
ReplyDeleteYeah, the results are basically the same regardless of which is the server and which is the client. There's definitely something on the Win7 box thats keeping the TCP window from scaling on its own correctly. When I use iPerf between Linux clients the default window size appears to adjust to something in the 900K to the 1M range when the client side connects to the server. With Win7 the default always maxes out at 64K and the speed would indicate that it's not scaling beyond that. Only way I can get it to go faster is to explicitly set the Window size higher in iPerf or use multiple TCP streams. There's got to be a config on the Win7 side I'm missing that allows RWIN to auto scale above 64K.
Deletedo you have a packet capture i can look at?
DeleteIIRC win 7 have some tuning options for the tcp stack - are they in their default values?
Here's a pcap with LSO on:
Deletehttps://drive.google.com/file/d/0B7vCQgqzBIZ7Q3poMmY0MUs5WnM/edit?usp=sharing
And LSO off:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B7vCQgqzBIZ7QjVKMkU3OXIxX28/edit?usp=sharing
I've used TCPOptimizer to implement better values for Win7, did give about a 1Gbps increase in speed, but nowhere near 10Gbps total
in your capture, 10.10.1.130 has Windows Scaling disabled, which means it can only grow to 65K. i assume this is the windows 7 machine ? It would explain why RWIN doesn't scale beyond 65K and impacts performance.
DeleteWindows 7 should have TCP WS enabled by default, something must have disabled it on your machine. take a look here http://datacomguy.blogspot.com/2011/06/tweaking-windows-7-vista-tcpip-settings.html
try manually changing autotuninglevel to normal or experimental (netsh int tcp set global autotuninglevel=normal)
Nice write-up! This led me to the discovery that my Oracle Solaris 11.1 VM was running the older Solaris 10 vmxnet3 NIC drivers.
ReplyDeleteBut after replacing the drivers and rebooting, the max MTU is still only 1500.
I noticed that the ping command you're using to test jumbo frames might be flawed. It's missing the parameter that sets the DF-bit on the echo-request packets.
Under Oracle Solaris 11.1, the following ping command will test jumbo frames.
ping -s -D 192.168.1.202 8972 4
One more thing, would you mind posting the output of 'dladm show-linkprop -p mtu' from your Solaris 11.1 guest VM?
I too have the same problem as Pooch that I can't seem to get past 2Gbps (default window size) VM-to-VM (both VMs are Win 7 and I have assigned each with 4 cpu). One thing for sure, the speed seems to affected by how many cpu each VM has (if I assign each VM with 1 cpu, the speed drop to <100Mbps).
ReplyDeleteHi Cyber Explorer, is it ok for you to show us your Host machine spec? (you have dual 10Gb ethernet onboard or PCIe adapter, CPU model, how much RAM, etc) As well as your VM setup? (you use vmxnet3, Virtual Machine Version 8 or 9 or 10, how many CPU assigned to each VM, memory, etc). In additional, do you use vsphere "client" or "web client" (with vcenter installed) to create those VM?
I am trying to follow your setup and see if I can get close to ~20Gbps and that would be extremely awesome!
Here is some test result and he too get around 2Gbps (default window size) as well
http://forums.freenas.org/threads/esxi-5-5-network-performance-comparison-with-vmxnet-and-intel-em.15320/
This is common in any communications protocol. In TCP / IP (TCP Offload, Full Kernel Bypass) each of these units of information called "datagram" (datagram), and data sets are sent as separate messages.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing nice blog....
Thanks for approving my comment.
ReplyDeleteIt is extremely interesting for me to read the article. Thank you for it. I like such topics and everything connected to them. I would like to read a bit more on that blog soon.
10G bit tcp offload
Full TCP offload engine works best with 10 gigabytes Ethernet network adapters. 10G bit TCP offload technology designed for financial institutions like banks, data centers, stock exchanges etc.
ReplyDeleteNIC with Full TCP/UDP offload
Thanks..
This is stylish MINK FUR and this is weather for winter and girl dress .and this name is ASTRAKAN AND MINK FUR .Thanks for is blog share is blog my favrate .
ReplyDeleteVMware has started fixing the bug in the Tools installation script, for example see http://kb.vmware.com/kb/2110233
ReplyDeleteFinally the LSO bug has been squashed. In the 9.4.15 version of vmware-tools.
ReplyDeleteI'm trying to boost my speed from my Win7 VM to my Ubuntu12.04 VM and I can't seem to get past 2Gbps in either direction. From what I can tell I have Jumbo Frames enabled on both and I'm using the VMXNET3 driver on each. Link states 10gbps on each. When I just run the default client and servers I'm stuck at 2Gbps but if I explicitly set the window size with the -w flag on each I can get up to about 6Gbps. My questions are: if TCP is configured properly shouldn't the window size scale automatically without being set? When I transfer files over SMB/CIFS obd2 scanner. I can't seem to move past the 2Gbps limit either (I've got an SSD capable of going faster)
ReplyDeleteThat gives off an impression of being fabulous
ReplyDeleteanyway i am still not very beyond any doubt that I like it.
At any rate will look much more into it and choose by and by! unkindesign
http://www.unkindesign.com/
It’s a pity you don’t have a donate button! I’d most certainly donate to
ReplyDeletethis outstanding blog! I suppose for visit here now i’ll settle for book-marking
and adding your RSS feed to my Google account.
I look forward to new updates and will talk about this
website with my Facebook group. Chat soon!
Classical music we are often in diseluk by young children now, but if we see and hear in more detail we know music klasih very cool and interesting, let's visit our web here ,, !!!!
ReplyDeleteobat kuat maxman
ReplyDeleteobat kuat obat kuat black ant africa
alat bantu sex pria vagina senter
boneka sex full body
alat bantu sex pria vagina pinggul
alat bantu sex pria vagina getar
celana hernia
alat bantu sex pria vagina manual
alat bantu sex wanita penis pretty love
viberator lidah
definately enjoy every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog! click here
ReplyDeleteIt turns out that even the hottest port has a few places where you can get off the beaten path. Here are some recommendations that will make you feel like you're in the know diebesten vpn
ReplyDeleteIt is a well-structured instruction which contains a few significant for considering points! Thank you for the submission!
ReplyDeleteWonderful blog! I found it while browsing on Yahoo News
ReplyDeleteRegards= office.com/setup
Outstanding post, nice guide, thanks!
ReplyDeleteLearn how install aol desktop gold for windows 10 and mac book. Aol desktop easy to use.AOL Desktop Gold When you start downloading or introduce AOL work area gold on your PC, start the operation.Aol gold desktop is Download generally famous for its highlights and capacities now accessible with every single new UI and advance security highlights.
ReplyDeleteHow to Install Microsoft Office: Visit office.com/setup. First, you obsession to ensnare the Official Microsoft Website www.office.com/setup. Sign in as soon as your Microsoft account. Enter your Product Key. Download and Run Office Setup. Run the Installation. You'regarding all set
ReplyDeleteAOL Desktop Gold is most likely the best device for getting to automated substances yet every once in a while, consumers face several issues with the product because of equipment or a product imperfection. In this manner, in some cases, customers get disappointed with AOL Gold programming and plan to uninstall the product. This instructional exercise blog tells the best way to uninstall Aol Desktop Gold software on Windows. Although, you may contact us AOL Gold customer care for help. The insistence simply removes AOL Gold from your device quickly.
ReplyDeleteYou may decide to perform the site-specific arrangement, such as the bathroom every Monday, the study room every Tuesday, the hallway every Wednesday, and so on.شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالدمام
ReplyDeleteشركة مكافحة حشرات بالدمام
شركة رش مبيدات بالدمام
افضل شركة مكافحة حشرات
roku.com/link
ReplyDeleteRoku Com Link
www.roku.com/link
Roku Link Activation Code
Roku account setup
Activate Roku Code
Roku Error Code Setup
Roku contact Support
Lets Activate your Roku Account
Roku Activation Code - smartcomlink.com
The Norton Setup at norton.com/Setup Norton setup is a process where reach you enter the Norton Setup Key at www.norton.com/setup to trigger & install Norton product. One can get your hands on Norton from retail include or online.
ReplyDeletethis blog is very important.norton.com/Setup
ReplyDeletenorton.com/setup - visit www.norton.com/setup to download, install, activate, reinstall Norton setup. Also get Norton setup 25 digit product key here.
ReplyDeleteseaport hack Excellent trick this great friend, this was what I was looking for a long time and finally something that works. I recommend them all if it is real is not a lie. Thanks friend. Keep it up
ReplyDeleteicloud storage hack -: If you will dial our iCloud client support telephone number and you need to converse with our specialists since they have extraordinary information and dealing with your issues for different sorts to the glitches of specialized.
ReplyDeleteClick Here -: https://icloudstorage.us/
Follow Us On Twitter -: https://twitter.com/icloudstorage2
Follow Us On Pinterest -: https://www.pinterest.com/icloudstorage/
Follow Us On You Tube -: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCqPXWuVJAuHLsNpFvxRrX9A
icloud hacking explained -: Clients will get autonomous help on the off chance that they utilize our help number.The above highlights help you to think about the outsider technical support number which you will impart utilizing the help telephone number. The customers should make it understood before utilizing the help telephone number that it doesn't have any association with the official client assistance telephone number of that specific brand or item. I am a digital marketing expert we will provide all kind of services in any site. We will also Satisfy our any customer that he or she will given project.You will call us on Toll-Free Number +1 804 480 2153 that you will get all satisfaction.
ReplyDeleteClick Here -: https://icloudweb.co/
We offer complete help for your primevideo.com/mytv device. From the underlying purpose of initiating your gadget till where your channels are flawlessly spilling, we provide step by step assistance. You may have inquiries on initiating the gadget and setting up with all the most loved channels and putting it up inside and out; Prime video helpline has all the orders to sift through all the inquiry you have. We assist with fixing your myTV gadgets, be it initiating it or becoming acquainted with about the Channel list on Roku or in any event, repairing your Roku remote. If you facing any queries related to prime video or mytv, Roku or Android devices Setup contact us, our expert's team always available customer help.
ReplyDeleteRead more…
تاینی موویز
ReplyDeleteدانلود آهنگ جدید
دانلود آهنگ مهستی
دانلود آهنگ قدیمی
دانلود آهنگ
دانلود آهنگ خارجی
دانلود آهنگ
If you face any problem regarding SBC Global email then contact us on our SBCGlobal Support Number.
ReplyDeleteRead More : - SBCGlobal Customer Support Phone Number | SBCGlobal Customer Service
The information is very useful. Thank you for sharing this amazing post, I really appreciate your work. keep going
ReplyDeletemcafee.com/activate | office.com/setup | www.office.com/setup | mcafee.com/activate
Norton offers top-notch features to protect your online data spread across the various devices. The features include timely updates, customized scanning, detection and protection from virus and malware.
ReplyDeleteNorton.com/setup
Norton.com/setup
Thanks for sharing this great post. If you need any kind of Amazon.com myTV activate related any queries contact us. Amazon prime customer care team always available for customer suitability and fix your issue instantly.
ReplyDeleteChase Bank gives customers to verify their credit card receipt and activate the card from home or anyplace over the Chase Com Verify Card conveniently. If you are facing any glitches with your card so simply visit Chase.com/verifycard contact us. Chase bank customer care always ready to help our customers and resolve issues as soon as possible.
ReplyDeleteRead More
Get Started with AOL Desktop Gold Download for Windows, 7, 8, 10 and MAC OS.
ReplyDeleteJust Follow link &
Click Download AOL Desktop Gold to start the process :
Aol Desktop Gold Download
https://sites.google.com/view/aol-desktop-gold-problems/aol-desktop-gold
Chase Verify Card – Chase bank Credit Card clients can confirm and activate online at chase.com. In the event that you have just applied for a Credit Card of Chase Bank, you ought to activate it by confirming it online at Bank's authentic site is www.chase.com. On the off chance that you "How would I enact my interest Credit Card?" Are searching for. So read the cycle beneath to confirm the card, at that point activate it.
ReplyDeleteRead More…
Escorts Service in Daman | Escorts Service in Diu | Escorts Service in Allahabad | Escorts Service in Greater Noida | Escorts Service in Kanpur
ReplyDeleteAmazon.com/mytv is provide you unlimited new movies and new latest tv serial.in my blog i will provide you step by step process how to use Amazon.com/mytv, Amazon codeus, Amazon.com/code and Amazon.com/redeem voucher.The MyTV Code is a free application that can be downloaded for free and will let you watch TV on your PC. It's not a TV provider app; it works with any computer that can view web pages.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteIf you are having trouble registering upward or signing up to YouTube TV, you may possibly well be signed directly into a Brand New Account. New Accounts Aren't harmonious with YouTube TV. You Will Need to use another Google Account to signal upward and signal into YouTube TV.
youtube.com/activate
www.youtube.com/activate
Paypal annual error resolution notice is related to your Paypal transaction. if you find any type error in this notice you can contact with Paypal office they will solve your request between 10 to 60 days. This report tell us about any unauthorized transaction and any kind error.
ReplyDeleteTubi's complimentary streaming agency is a pleasing surprise, even with a vast assortment of quirky and classic pictures and television collection. It's ad-supported, nevertheless, you'll run in to more adverts on freetoair than simply while seeing among Tubi's b movies.
ReplyDeletetubi.tv/activate
tubi.tv/activate enter code
tubi.tv/activate
Paypal is the most use wallet for money transaction purpose. you can add paypal with different Apps who make our transaction easy. if you want to know how to link Your paypal account with ebay then come to my blog. where i will tell you how you can add paypal account with ebay who is a biggest shopping and auction platforms.
ReplyDeleteSBCGlobal is one of the advanced emails used to send and receive messages, documents, gifs, etc. It was merged with an AT&T email. You can login to the SBCGlobal email account using AT&T email with a valid user id and password. Reset your SBCGlobal email account password using security questions or temporary password methods. If you have any recovery email or mobile number, you will get a text code in it. It depends upon your choice to select the most suitable methods for receiving a code. Enter the received code or temporary password to reset the SBCGlobal email password. For any problem, you must call the sbcglobal customer service phone number to fix this issue.
ReplyDeleteRead more: sbcglobal customer care phone number
QuickBooks is an accounting software widely used by companies to manage their accounts, payrolls, and many other tasks effortlessly. Yet, it sometimes encounters an QuickBooks Error Code C = 272 which can hamper the company and client's data. The quickest tweak to fix this error is by disabling the Windows Compatible Mode via QuickBooks Desktop Shortcut Icon. And next step is to disable Windows Compatibility Mode for QBW32.exe files. In the case of technical queries, users can freely contact Quickbooks customer service number. You can talk to their highly qualified technician to have the best possible solution to your problem.
ReplyDeleteRead more: QuickBooks Error Code 15101
activate Youtubecom
ReplyDeleteSamsung Smart TVs ... to sign in: on your phone or computer,
go to Youtube.com/activate
and enter the code you see on your TV.
Our the purpose is to share the reviews about the latest Jackets,Coats and Vests also shre the related Movies,Gaming, Casual,Faux Leather and Leather materials available Maynard James Keenan Leather Jacket
ReplyDeleteHi , Thank you so much for writing such an informational blog. If you are Searching for latest Jackets, Coats and Vests, for more info click on given link-ACDC Jacket
ReplyDeleterastgele görüntülü konuşma - kredi hesaplama - instagram video indir - instagram takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - tiktok takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - instagram beğeni satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - binance güvenilir mi - binance güvenilir mi - binance güvenilir mi - binance güvenilir mi - instagram beğeni satın al - instagram beğeni satın al - polen filtresi - google haritalara yer ekleme - btcturk güvenilir mi - binance hesap açma - kuşadası kiralık villa - tiktok izlenme satın al - instagram takipçi satın al - sms onay - paribu sahibi - binance sahibi - btcturk sahibi - paribu ne zaman kuruldu - binance ne zaman kuruldu - btcturk ne zaman kuruldu - youtube izlenme satın al - torrent oyun - google haritalara yer ekleme - altyapısız internet - bedava internet - no deposit bonus forex - erkek spor ayakkabı - webturkey.net - karfiltre.com - tiktok jeton hilesi - tiktok beğeni satın al - microsoft word indir - misli indir
ReplyDeleteMicrosoft 365 provides more security than a basic Office 365 subscription, with features such as Enhanced Security Features, wireless cleaning, and app safety and security that prevents duplication.. Instead of using Microsoft Word and Excel, Microsoft 365 offers a range of useful features.
ReplyDeletemicrosoft365.com/setup
office.com/renew
office365.com/setup
microsoft365.com/setup
office.com/renew
office365.com/setup
Home and Student 2019 is designed for students and families who choose to use classic Office software such as Excel, Word, and PowerPoint on Windows and Mac. It’s a one-time purchase that can be used at home or in the classroom on one PC or Mac.
ReplyDeleteoffice.com/setup home and student 2019
office.com/setup home and business 2019
office.com/setup home and student 2019
office.com/setup home and business 2019
Visit our website and Troubleshoot the most commonly occuring errors of Microsoft office by the easiest steps. Install, and activate your Office setup on your computer and other devices.
ReplyDeleteoffice.com/setup
www.office.com/setup
office.com/setup
www.office.com/setup
How can I make Yahoo my homepage on Chrome?
ReplyDeleteIf you’re wondering how to make Yahoo my homepage on Chrome, follow the steps mentioned here. First of all, open Google Chrome and click on the Settings icon. Choose the Settings option from the menu. Under the Settings window, you need to click "Open a specific page or set of pages" located under On Startup. Click on Set pages option. This will open the Startup pages window. After this, enter www.Yahoo.com in the Add a new page section and lastly, click OK to confirm it.
Also Read:-
verizon customer service
change facebook password on iphone
how to turn off comments on facebook marketplace
why is facebook unresponsive
how to recover permanently deleted facebook account
how to disable facebook account
lock facebook profile
how to bypass two-factor authentication facebook
can't upload video to facebook
facebook not working
youtube abone satın al
ReplyDeletecami avizesi
cami avizeleri
avize cami
no deposit bonus forex 2021
takipçi satın al
takipçi satın al
takipçi satın al
takipcialdim.com/tiktok-takipci-satin-al/
instagram beğeni satın al
instagram beğeni satın al
btcturk
tiktok izlenme satın al
sms onay
youtube izlenme satın al
no deposit bonus forex 2021
tiktok jeton hilesi
tiktok beğeni satın al
binance
takipçi satın al
uc satın al
sms onay
sms onay
tiktok takipçi satın al
tiktok beğeni satın al
twitter takipçi satın al
trend topic satın al
youtube abone satın al
instagram beğeni satın al
tiktok beğeni satın al
twitter takipçi satın al
trend topic satın al
youtube abone satın al
takipcialdim.com/instagram-begeni-satin-al/
perde modelleri
instagram takipçi satın al
instagram takipçi satın al
takipçi satın al
instagram takipçi satın al
betboo
marsbahis
sultanbet
marsbahis
ReplyDeletebetboo
sultanbet
marsbahis
betboo
sultanbet
yasaklı sitelere giriş
ReplyDeletepepsi kodları
wall hack kodu
ücretsiz antivirüs programları
yeni kimlik yenileme ücreti
internetsiz oyunlar
en hızlı dns sunucuları
hız testi
tiktok jeton hilesi
Thanks a lot for sharing this post
ReplyDeleteYahoo Customer Service
Ucuz, kaliteli ve organik sosyal medya hizmetleri satın almak için Ravje Medyayı tercih edebilir ve sosyal medya hesaplarını hızla büyütebilirsin. Ravje Medya ile sosyal medya hesaplarını organik ve gerçek kişiler ile geliştirebilir, kişisel ya da ticari hesapların için Ravje Medyayı tercih edebilirsin. Ravje Medya internet sitesine giriş yapmak için hemen tıkla: ravje.com
ReplyDeleteİnstagram takipçi satın almak için Ravje Medya hizmetlerini tercih edebilir, güvenilir ve gerçek takipçilere Ravje Medya ile ulaşabilirsin. İnstagram takipçi satın almak artık Ravje Medya ile oldukça güvenilir. Hemen instagram takipçi satın almak için Ravje Medyanın ilgili sayfasını ziyaret et: instagram takipçi satın al
Tiktok takipçi satın al istiyorsan tercihini Ravje Medya yap! Ravje Medya uzman kadrosu ve profesyonel ekibi ile sizlere Tiktok takipçi satın alma hizmetide sunmaktadır. Tiktok takipçi satın almak için hemen tıkla: tiktok takipçi satın al
İnstagram beğeni satın almak için Ravje medya instagram beğeni satın al sayfasına giriş yap, hızlı ve kaliteli instagram beğeni satın al: instagram beğeni satın al
Youtube izlenme satın al sayfası ile hemen youtube izlenme satın al! Ravje medya kalitesi ile hemen youtube izlenme satın almak için tıklayın: youtube izlenme satın al
Twitter takipçi satın almak istiyorsan Ravje medya twitter takipçi satın al sayfasına tıkla, Ravje medya güvencesi ile organik twitter takipçi satın al: twitter takipçi satın al
You were great and everyone received so much from your experience and knowledge
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely amazing, thank you for sharing your knowledge with me. 메이저사이트
Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site Black Label Society Vest
ReplyDeleteGreat post again! great job. And I am satisfied to read your article. you can fill your visa application form turkey & within 24 hour you can get your visa and pay Turkey e visa cost.The process is very simple, all you have to do is fill our online application form.
ReplyDeleteI am browsing this website daily and get good facts from here all the time. Aw, this was a really nice post. Kenya evisa processing time, Kenyans can apply for their eVisa in about 15 minutes by filling and submitting the visa application form.
ReplyDeleteNice Blog !
ReplyDeleteHere We are Specialist in Manufacturing of Movies, Gaming, Casual, Faux Leather Jackets, Coats And Vests See. Killmonger Denim Jacket
Are you entangle with the issue of Facebook search not working? Every time when trying to do a search on Facebook, search bar does not work. Then don't worry, know how you can fix it by visiting the website.
ReplyDeleteYour article has answered the question I was wondering about! I would like to write a thesis on this subject, but I would like you to give your opinion once :Dsòng bạc
ReplyDeleteThe streams that run on FOX, NBC, beIN Sports and many more. For connecting your tv to the fubo tv, your tv needs to be smart or android or if not, then install the devices such as Roku or amazon fire stick to continue.
ReplyDeleteFubo tv connect
Fubo tv connect
tiktok jeton hilesi
ReplyDeletetiktok jeton hilesi
binance referans kimliği
gate güvenilir mi
tiktok jeton hilesi
paribu
btcturk
bitcoin nasıl alınır
yurtdışı kargo
Wow.. Very informative article.. Indian visa fees depend on your nationality and your visa type. You can pay for the Indian tourist visa fee securely. You don't need to worry about losing your information.
ReplyDeletealiağa
ReplyDeletealsancak
turgutreis
gölbaşı
mamak
darıca
çarşamba
silifke
esenyurt
Because you've seen this tweet, wherever you name is mentioned, Grace will speak for you.
ReplyDeletecomprare patente di Guida
comprar carta de conducao
420Buds
Rijbewijs kopen
ReplyDeleteführerschein kaufen
comprare patente
Acheter permis de conduire en france
Kupiti vozačka dozvola
comprar carta de conduçao
comprar carta de conduçao
ReplyDeletecomprare patente
kok korekort
comprar carta de carro
koupit řidičský průkaz
rijbewijs-kopen-belgie
Amazing post
ReplyDeletecomprare patente di Guida
comprar carta de conducao
420Buds
thrilling post
ReplyDeletecomprare patente di Guida
comprar carta de conducao
420Buds
Rijbewijs kopen
ReplyDeleteführerschein kaufen
comprare patente
Acheter permis de conduire en france
Kupiti vozačka dozvola
This post is Amazing
ReplyDeletecomprare patente di Guida
comprar carta de conducao
420Buds
Fubo tv was established in 2015 and during that time it was famous for streaming live football shows but nowadays including football, all the sports events such as NBA, NFL, MLB are being hosted by Fubo tv connect.
ReplyDeleteFubo tv connect
Fubo.tv/connect
comprare patente
ReplyDeleteRijbewijs kopen
Acheter permis de conduire en france
führerschein kaufen
Kupiti vozačka dozvola
führerschein kaufen
ReplyDeletecomprare patente
comprar carta de conduçao
Rijbewijs kopen
Acheter permis de conduire en france
Kupiti vozačka dozvola
ReplyDeletecomprare patente
Rijbewijs kopen
führerschein kaufen
comprare patente
comprar carta de conduçao
Carta de Conducao
ReplyDeleteRijbewijs Kopen
Buy driving license
ADR Schein kaufen
ReplyDeletePKW führerschein kaufen
ADR Schein ihk kaufen
führerschein kaufen
Rijbewijs kopen
comprare patente
comprare patente
ReplyDeletecomprare patente b Napoli
come comprare la patente
compra patente
comprare la patente nautica
comprare la patente
best info on this site
ReplyDeletehttps://acquistapatentediguida.com/dove-comprare-una-patente-di-guida/
https://acquistapatentediguida.com/comprare-patente-di-guide/
https://acquistapatentediguida.com/come-ottenere-una-patente-di-guida-italiana/
rijbewijs kopen
ReplyDeletenederlands-rijbewijs
geregistreerd-rijbewijs-kopen-2021
betrouwbaar-rijbewijs
ReplyDeleterijbewijs-kopen-in-belgie
rijbewijs-kopen-voor-nederland
authentiekrijbewijs
comprare patente
ReplyDeletekupiti vozacka dozvola
führerschein kaufen
Rijbewijs kopen
comprare patente
ADR Schein kaufen
comprar carta de conduçao
ReplyDeletecomprar carta de condução verdadeira
comprar carta de carro
comprar carta de condução lisboa
imt carta de condução
führerschein kaufen
ReplyDeletecomprare patente
comprar carta de conduçao
Rijbewijs kopen
kupiti vozacka dozvola
comprare patente
ADR Schein kaufen
Your post is very interesting to me. Reading was so much fun. I think the reason reading is fun is because it is a post related to that I am interested in. Articles related to 블랙잭 you are the best. I would like you to write a similar post about !
ReplyDeleteführerschein kaufen
ReplyDeletecomprare patente
comprar carta de carro
ADR Schein kaufen
Rijbewijs kopen
kupiti vozacka dozvola
comprare patente
ReplyDeleteAwesome.. geweldig...grymt bra...fantastisch
Kopa Korkort
Rijbewijs Kopen
fuhrerschein kaufen
comprare patente
acheter permis de conduire belgique
acheter permis de conduire en suisse
führerschein kaufen schweiz
rijbewijs Kopen België
nederlands-rijbewijs
comprare patente di Guida
ReplyDeleteacquista la tua patente italian frivers
ReplyDeleteAcquistapatentediguida
Servizi
Chi Siamo
DomandeFrequenti
comeottenereunapatentediguidasenzaesamediguida
I am very impressed to read this blog. I hope you will continue to upload similar blogs. Thank you very much. I have an online store with the name FLYING LEATHER JACKET please visit for an awesome collection.
ReplyDeleteMEN AVIATOR LEATHER JACKETS
B3 BOMBER JACKETS
MOTOGP LEATHER SUIT
MOTOGP LEATHER JACKETS
I saw this amazing article and felt you should see it. Check it out and get new tips
ReplyDeleteAcquistapatentediguida
Servizi
Chi Siamo
DomandeFrequenti
comeottenereunapatentediguidasenzaesamediguida
contattaci
We are looking for an informative post it is very helpful thanks for sharing it. We are offering all types of leather jackets with worldwide free shipping.
ReplyDeleteBlack Leather Jacket
Leather Bomber Jacket
Mens Biker Leather Jacket
Western Leather Jackets
comprar carta de conduçao
ReplyDeletecomprar carta de condução verdadeira
comprar carta de carro
comprar-carta-de-conducao-legal/
comprare-patente-b
comprare la patente
comprare patente
come comprare la patente
Thank you for sharing. Nice article you have here Buy Steroids Online moreover the admin of this site has really worked hard for all this once more thanks for sharing your articles.
ReplyDeleteBuy Oxytropin Online
Buy Soliris Online
Buy Humatrope Online
Buy Hcg Online
Buy Enanthate Online
Buy Parabolan Online
Buy Trenbolone Online
Buy Testo-Prop Online
Buy PrimobolanOnline
Buy Serostim Online
Buy Deca Online
Buy Testanon Online
Buy Tri-Tren Online
Buy NPP Online
Buy Turinabol Online
Buy Anadrol Online
Buy Anavar Online
Buy Boldenone Online
Buy Testosterone Cypionate Online
Buy Winstrol Online
Buy Masteron Online
Buy Clenbuterol Online
Buy Danabol Online
PKW führerschein kaufen
ReplyDeletempu kaufen
fuhrerschein-kaufen-ohne-vorkasse/
ADR Schein ihk kaufen
führerschein kaufen
ADR Schein kaufen
comprare-patente-b
ReplyDeletecomprare la patente
comprar carta de conduçao
comprar carta de condução verdadeira
comprar carta de carro
comprar-carta-de-conducao-legal/
comprare patente
come comprare la patente
Merkur 15c Safety Razor - Barber Pole - Deccasino
ReplyDeleteMerkur 15C Safety Razor - Merkur - 사설 토토 사이트 15C for worrione Barber Pole is 출장안마 the https://jancasino.com/review/merit-casino/ perfect introduction deccasino to the Merkur Safety Razor.
https://highlandelectronics.net/
ReplyDeleteWe are famous among the best electronics online store, especially when you Buy Playstation Online, Xbox for sale, Apple
phone accessories and more.
https://highlandelectronics.net/
text/whatsapp : +1(702) 637-0962
Buy Canaan Avalon Miner 1166 Pro
Canaan Avalon Miner 1166 Pro
Buy Antminer Z15 420sol/s
Antminer Z15 420sol/s
IPad Pro 12.9-inch for sale
Buy IPad Pro 12.9-inch online
Buy STM Charge Tree Swing online
Order STM Charge Tree Swing
Apple iPhone 13 Pro Max Gold for sale
Apple iPhone 13 Pro Max Gold
Apple iPhone 13 Pro 128GB Gold for sale
Buy Apple iPhone 13 Pro Gold
Buy Apple Watch Series 7 Online
Apple Watch Series 7 for sale
Buy iPhone 13 Pro Max online
iPhone 13 Pro Max for sale online
Buy iPhone 13 Pro online
iPhone 13 Pro for sale
order iPhone 13 pro
iPhone 13 for sale online
Buy iPhone 13 online
Order iPhone 13 online
Buy iPad Air 10.9-inch Online
iPad Air 10.9-inch for sale
Buy MacBook Air 13-inch Online
MacBook Air 13-inch for sale
Wholesale MacBook Pro 13 online
Buy MacBook Pro 13 online
Buy ASUS Chromebook Flip C434 Online
ASUS Chromebook Flip C434
Buy Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Online
kupiti vozacka dozvola
ReplyDeletecomprare patente
comprare patente
Rijbewijs kopen
comprar carta de carro
führerschein kaufen
ADR Schein kaufen
acheter permis de conduire
patente b
ReplyDeletepatente-a
rinnovo patente
quiz patente
comprare patente
that was an amazing post, good all through
ReplyDeleteCarta de Conducao
Buy driving license
Comprar Licencia de Conducir
Permis de Conduire
Genuine IELTS Certicate without exams
Kup Prawo Jazdy
rijbewijs kopen Nederland
Kup Prawo Jazdy
geregistreerd-rijbewijs-kopen-2021
rijbewijs kopen
incredible, need information such as this
rijbewijs kopen
ReplyDeletenederlands-rijbewijs
geregistreerd-rijbewijs-kopen-2021
betrouwbaar-rijbewijs
acheter permis de conduire
ReplyDeletekupiti vozacka dozvola
comprare patente
comprare patente
Rijbewijs kopen
comprar carta de carro
führerschein kaufen
ADR Schein kaufen
Bootsführerschein Kaufen
ReplyDeleteacheter permis de conduire
kupiti vozacka dozvola
comprare patente
comprare patente
Rijbewijs kopen
comprar carta de carro
führerschein kaufen
Patente di guida italiana
ReplyDeletepatente b
patente-a
rinnovo patente
quiz patente
comprare patente
rijbewijs kopen
ReplyDeletecomprare la patente
führerschein kaufen
ADR Schein kaufen
acheter permis de conduire
kupiti vozacka dozvola
comprar carta de conduçao
comprare patente
Bootsführerschein Kaufen
Comprare patente di guida
ReplyDeletecomprare la patente
patente internazionale
patente di guida legittima
comprare patente b Napoli
comprare patente b
I no uncertainty esteeming each and every bit of it. It is an amazing site and superior to anything normal give. I need to grateful. Marvelous work! Every one of you complete an unfathomable blog, and have some extraordinary substance. Keep doing stunning 메이저사이트순위
ReplyDeleteYour article is what I've been looking for for a long time. I'm happy to find you like this. Could you visit my website if you have time? I'm sure you'll find a post of interest that you'll find interesting. 슬롯커뮤니티
ReplyDeleteIt is a great pleasure to read your message. I like it because it contains a lot of information I'm looking for and I like to comment The Turkish visa application form can be filled online from virtually anywhere in the world, so visitors from anywhere in the world can obtain their visa via email.
ReplyDeleteI like the helpful info you provide in your articles. I’ll bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I’m quite sure I’ll learn plenty of new stuff right here! Good luck for the next. 스포츠토토
ReplyDeleteThanks for taking the time to talk about it; it's something I was very excited to know about. I just inform you that now you can Build an Al-driven application to do business faster, and more efficiently. AI apps are most appreciated in any business.
ReplyDelete출장출장샵
ReplyDelete출장출장샵
출장출장샵
출장출장샵
출장출장샵
출장출장샵
출장출장샵
출장출장샵
출장출장샵
Media Foster is the best SEO company who is known for providing result-oriented white hat & best SEO services at Mohali for all businesses. if you need more information visit our website.
ReplyDelete출장샵
출장샵
출장샵
출장샵
출장샵
출장샵
nice article google
ReplyDeletewhich is the best video editor forsports highlight /video editor for filmmaking Video Editor For MKV Files video editor for mp4 files I read this post your post so nice and very informative post thanks for sharing this post,Great article. Couldn’t be write much better! Keep it up linktr manylink nordVPN 6 month dealnordVPN 2 year plan
ReplyDeleteThis is an open access article distributed under the phrases of the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives License 4.0 (CCBY-NC-ND), the place it is permissible to download and share the work offered it is correctly cited. 온라인카지노 The work can't be changed in any means or used commercially with out permission from the journal. Balance gambling with different activities.Gambling shouldn't intervene with, or take the place of, friends, household, work, or different pleasant activities. Set a time limit and persist with it.Decide how long you wish to gambling.
ReplyDelete0978675645465768798 iugfgdfsdfdgfhgjhkj 89786756453465768798 kjhjghfgdfsdgfhgjhk
ReplyDeletescottish fold munchkin kittens for sale near me
scottish fold munchkin cat for sale near me
scottish fold munchkins for sale
scottish fold munchkin near me
scottish fold munchkin kitten for sale
세종출장샵
ReplyDelete통영출장샵
전국 예약비 없는 출장
속초예약금없는출장샵
출장샵선입금
이천출장샵
führerschein kaufen ohne prüfung
ReplyDeleteacheter un permis de conduire
khttpsupiti vozačku dozvolu
rijbewijs-kopen
Comprare Patente
uk drivers license
The information in this article is very important to me. I want to thank you for making this free content available, and I hope that my colleagues will read it. Black Label Society vest
ReplyDeleteI will use this article in my class as a reference because it's very useful for students. Black Label Society vest
ReplyDeleteMens luxury t shirts
ReplyDeleteSuts iegadajieties uzvalku pecpasutijuma
Trajes de hombre
%e5%8f%a4%e9%a9%b0/
Chinese yuan to usd
doja cat
fashion
modedesigner/
Buy NCLEX without Exam
ReplyDeleteBuy SSN
buy US Driver’s License
Buy Cloned Cards
ReplyDeleteCloned Cards Shop
Buy Cloned Visa Cards
Buy Cloned Master Cards